Looking for planning advice? Reach out to us or check out our blog for more info.

Wedding Guest Book Alternatives

Looking for a unique way to collect signatures and well-wishes from wedding guests? Check out our Wedding Guest Book Alternative Frame and Signing Corks Collection. This collection features a corkboard frame and a set of corks that guests can sign with their messages of love and congratulations. It's a fun and creative way to preserve memories from your special day!

13 products


  • Sale -10% Personalized Mr. & Mrs. Glass Wedding Wishes Guest Book Jar Personalized Mr. & Mrs. Glass Wedding Wishes Guest Book Jar

    Personalized Mr. & Mrs. Glass Wedding Wishes Guest Book Jar

    49 in stock

    Instead of a simple guest book signature, your wedding reception guests can write out well wishes, marriage advice, date night ideas, or shared memories. The dancing dots wish sheets can then be collected through the drop-slot in the wood lid for the newlywed couple to read and display after the wedding day or if the dancing dots aren’t a perfect match for your wedding décor feel free to use your own paper sheets or note cards that are! The wish jar comes with four signage tent cards indicating what the bride and groom would like to see written as well as our dancing dots paper sheets and can be personalized by adding the couple’s family name, wedding date, or other custom text to the printed "Mr. & Mrs." design. Details: 4.8" (D) x 9" (H) Glass jar with bamboo wood lid Includes 4 assorted signage pieces to choose from: Wish Jar, Advice for the Couple, Time Capsule, and Date Night Ideas Includes 112 paper cards for your guests to write ideas, advice & wishes Bamboo lid features large opening for cards to be placed inside jar Bamboo lid is fully removable Holds 56oz (1550ml)

    49 in stock

    $49.99$44.99

  • Sale -13%Last stock! Special Delivery Wedding Ceremony Letter Box "Special Delivery" Vintage Wedding Ceremony Letter Box - A great guest book alternative.

    Special Delivery Wedding Ceremony Letter Box

    4 in stock

    Make it a Special Delivery with this attractive Letter Box Wedding Wishing Well.  Styled just like the mailboxes of long ago, this antique-styled letter box makes a fine replacement to the traditional guest book. Watch as your guests awe over its vintage embossed detailing when you add it to the guest book table. Sure to be a timeless keepsake for years to come when you store your family recipes or keepsakes.   Details:Dimensions: 7'' x 4 1/4'' x 12 1/2'' H Stationery sold separatelyOther items not includedEngraving option not picturedThe color of box may vary**This is a clearance item, no returns are accepted.Item#  9220

    4 in stock

    $44.99$38.99

  • Personalized Ombre Wedding Drop Box Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts Personalized Ombre Wedding Drop Box Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts

    Personalized Ombre Wedding Drop Box Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts

    299 in stock

    A charming white frame made in a shadow box style, the Wooden Heart Drop Shadow Box Frame Guest Book Alternative is a creative option for your guest sign-in. A modern alternative to traditional signature style guest books it’s perfect for your wedding reception, bridal shower, or engagement party. Instead of having party guests write their signatures register style, they can sign, write well-wishes, or put short messages on the cute heart shaped wooden pieces that come with the frame before dropping them through the slot at the top. Details:White wooden frame with an opening along the top edgeStyle: Signature Couple, lower casePlexiglass window100 wooden heartsFits approximately 80 wooden heartsSize: 19" (H) x 13" (W) x 3/4" (D)Materials; MDF frame, plexiglass, plywood heartsIncludes 100 wooden hearts and 3 paper background choices; white, pink aqueous, and navyPen and other items not includedSome assembly required/Instructions are included for assemblyItem# 5127Availability: In Stock

    299 in stock

    $44.99

  • Wedding Day Wedding Guest Book Blocks Stacking Game

    Wedding Day Wedding Guest Book Blocks Stacking Game

    Out of stock

    This Natural Wood Stacking Game Block Set will create a unique wedding ceremony guest book alternative. Invite your guests to write their names and wishes on a wooden block and add to the stacking wooden block tower. Great fun for guests of all ages, this engaging addition is not only is fun on your wedding day but the perfect keepsake for the many years that follow. See our complete: Wedding Guest Book Alternative Collection Details:Size: 3 1/2" (W) x 14" (H) x 3 1/2" (D)Materials: MDFPen not includedIncludes 72 wooden blocksItem# wood317

    Out of stock

    $48.99

  • Sale -24% Rustic Wedding Gift Carad Wishing Well Box

    Rustic Wedding Gift Card Wishing Well Box

    23 in stock

    Add a touch of rustic romance to your wedding with this charming burlap card box! This stunning box will make a beautiful addition to the décor of any rustic wedding or special event and provides guests with an easy spot to drop their cards with thoughtful gifts for you and your soon-to-be spouse. With its delicate lace bow, rustic jute trimming, and adorable heart charm, it’s no surprise that this Rustic Romance Card Box makes for a surefire way to brighten up your special day! Let your loved ones express their heartfelt wishes in the most stylish way possible - pick up this Rustic Romance Card Box today and make sure that every wedding gift stands out. Details: Dimensions: 10" x 10" x 10"Price Includes: Card box

    23 in stock

    $58.99$44.99

  • Sale -13% 50 Wooden Craft 1 1/2 -inch Wood Hearts 50 Wooden Craft 1-1/2-inch Wood Hearts

    50 Wooden Craft 1-1/2-inch Wood Hearts

    1000 in stock

    These Small Wooden Craft Hearts make it easy for your guests to leave a special message on your wedding day. Designed to write on with a felt tip pen (not included) then simply drop into a drop box guest book frame or add to any other decorative container to create a lasting keepsake that can be enjoyed for years to come. Great for decoration favor boxes and more. Suggested pen type, felt pen (not included). Use with our: Wedding Guest Book Alternative Collection Details:Sold in packages of 50Size: 1 1/2" (L) x 1 1/8" (H)Materials: PlywoodPen not includedItem# 4604Availability: In Stock

    1000 in stock

    $14.99$12.99

  • Sale -11% Personalized Drop Box Starry Night Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts Personalized Drop Box Starry Night Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts

    Personalized Drop Box Starry Night Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts

    98 in stock

    This darling starry night inspired Guest Book Alternative includes all of the recent guest book trends with a hint of the romantic night sky. The Personalized Starry Night Wedding Drop Box Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts will encourage your guests to write a brief message on a wooden heart and drop one into this dropbox frame for the bride and groom to read later. Suggested pen type, felt pen (not included). Personalized with 3 lines (+ included, other symbols will not be accepted). Also available in other designs: Wedding Guest Book Alternative Collection. Details:White wooden frame with an opening along the top edgePlexiglass window100 wooden heartsSize: 19" (H) x 13" (W) x 3/4" (D)Materials; MDF frame, plexiglass, plywood heartsPen not includedDate formatting: 00.00.00Item# 5127starAvailability: In Stock

    98 in stock

    $44.99$39.99

  • Sale -24% Date Night Personalized Glass Wedding Wishes Guest Book Jar Date Night Personalized Glass Wedding Wishes Guest Book Jar

    Date Night Personalized Glass Wedding Wishes Guest Book Jar

    49 in stock

    Simple but unique, the Custom Printed Wedding Well Wishes And Advice Jar Guest Book Alternative makes a fun choice for an alternative guest book. The clear glass jar is fashioned in a vase style with a footed pedestal and wooden bamboo lid making it an attractive, inexpensive display piece for your guest sign-in table. The wish jar comes with four signage tent cards indicating what the bride and groom would like to see written as well as our dancing dots paper sheets and can be personalized by adding the couple’s family name, wedding date, or other custom text to the printed "Date Night" design. Instead of a simple guest book signature, your wedding reception guests can write out date night ideas, well wishes, marriage advice, or shared memories. The dancing dots wish sheets can then be collected through the drop-slot in the wood lid for the newlywed couple to read and display after the wedding day or, if the dancing dots aren’t a perfect match for your wedding décor feel free to use your own paper sheets or note cards that are! Truly, the wish jar is a cheap, creative idea for a guest book and an elegant way to remind newlywed couples of the loved ones who helped them celebrate their happy day. Details:4.8" (D) x 9" (H) Glass jar with bamboo wood lid Includes 112 paper cards for your guests to write ideas, advice & wishes Bamboo lid features large opening for cards to be placed inside jar Bamboo lid is fully removable Holds 56oz (1550ml) Bamboo lid features a 3.25"(W) x 0.315"(H) opening for cards to be placed inside jar

    49 in stock

    $45.99$34.99

  • Sale -11% Personalized Drop Box Modern Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts Personalized Drop Box Modern Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts

    Personalized Drop Box Modern Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts

    300 in stock

    This darling Guest Book Alternative includes all of the recent guest book trends with a hint of stunning rustic charm. The Personalized DropBox Modern Guest Book Alternative with 100 Hearts will encourage your guests to write a brief message on a wooden heart and drop one into this dropbox frame for the bride and groom to read later. Suggested pen type, felt pen (not included). Personalized with 3 lines (+ included). Also available in other designs: Wedding Guest Book Alternative Collection. Details:White wooden frame with an opening along the top edgePlexiglass window100 wooden heartsSize: 19" (H) x 13" (W) x 3/4" (D)Materials; MDF frame, plexiglass, plywood heartsPen and easel not includedItem# 5127MCAvailability: In Stock

    300 in stock

    $44.99$39.99

  • Destination Wedding Passport Guest Book Kit "Our Journey Begins" Travel Inspired Alternative Guest Book Kit

    Destination Wedding Passport Guest Book Kit

    100 in stock

    Make a statement with this destination wedding inspired guest book. Featuring "Our Journey Begins" on the front, this passport styled travel guest book has unlimited possibilities. Your guests will stamp your 'destination wedding passport book' with one of the three stamp designs, write a special message or/and add a piece of marriage advice. The kit includes a 52-page passport style guest book, three assorted rubber stamps and an instruction card. Details:W 6 1/2'' x H 9 1/2''Materials: Faux Leather, Paper, Rubber Stamps with Wood HandlesKit includes a 52-page passport style guest book, three assorted rubber stamps and instruction cardInk pad not included Item# 9515Availability: In Stock

    100 in stock

    $49.99

  • Sale -14% White Wash Metal Decorative Bird Cage in Conservatory Design White Wash Metal Decorative Bird Cage in Conservatory Design

    White Wash Metal Decorative Bird Cage in Conservatory Design

    9999 in stock

    Add a love bird inspired decorative element that combines both beauty and function, the Metal Bird Cage Conservatory Style can be used to collect notes of well wishes from your guests, wedding greeting cards or filled with florals. Easily create a stunning addition to your wedding and party decorations. This classic decorative bird cage can be used time and time again. Details:Size: 14 1/6" (L) x 7 7/8" (W) x 18 1/9" (H)Materials: IronItem# 4477Availability: In Stock

    9999 in stock

    $69.99$59.99

  • "Circle of Love" Acrylic Wishing Well

    Circle of Love Acrylic Wishing Well

    10000 in stock

    This translucent contemporary acrylic box with "Circle of Love” details creates a sophisticated Wishing Well that will work with any wedding color theme. Coordinate with your favorite personalized note card theme for the perfect complement. It can be used as a well for guests, wedding cards or as a memory box for all your wedding keepsakes. Details:Materials - acrylicDimensions: 9 3/4' x 9 3/4' x 9 1/2 HPersonalized Well Wishing Cards sold separatelyItem# 9221Availability: In Stock

    10000 in stock

    $69.98

  • "Circle of Love" Wishing Well Personalized Cards in Fuchsia "Circle of Love" Wishing Well Personalized Cards

    Circle of Love Wishing Well Personalized Cards (Pack of 6)

    10000 in stock

    These contemporary interlocking Circle of Love double sided Wishing Well Personalized Cards will add the perfect pop of color to our Circle of Love Acrylic Wishing Well. Each card includes an area for guests to handwrite their well wishes. Details: Sold in packs of 6Minimum order of 4 packs of 6 required Width 5" x Height 5” Item# 1169-44-c92Availability: In Stock

    10000 in stock

    $3.60

Cake Decorations and Wedding Cake Toppers

Cake Decorations and Wedding Cake Toppers

Flavor inspiration, designs, decorating tips and more for every budget! Wedding party cake toppers, cake serving sets, cake decorations, knife and fork ceremony accessories and more.

Huge Sale on Birthday Party Supplies

Huge Sale on Birthday Party Supplies

Highlight a new collection and share details about products related to this image

Featured collection

Blog posts

  • , by Butter Be Mine Top Personalized Gift Ideas for Friends For 2023

    Read more 

  • , by Butter Be Mine How to Plan a Minimalist Wedding: Tips and Ideas for the Modern Bride and Groom

    Read more 

  • , by Butter Be Mine 10 EASY Steps to Set Up Lighting for Your Small to Medium Sized Backyard Event

    Read more 

  • , by Butter Be Mine A Step-by-Step Guide to Planning Your Own Wedding

    Read more 

Send us a message!

Contact form

© 2024 Butter Be Mine, Ecommerce Software by Shopify

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa

Login

Forgot your password?

Don't have an account yet?
Create account